×

Your Local, Family-Owned Agency

Since 1979, we've built our reputation on one simple promise: We work for you.

It is our pleasure to introduce you to Hometown Insurance – one of New York State's leading Independent Insurance Agencies. Our commitment is to serve you with the highest degree of professionalism. You can expect us to utilize our extensive knowledge and experience to act as your personal insurance advisers.

Our Mission:

At Hometown Insurance Agency, our mission is to empower business leaders, families, and communities with trusted guidance and ironclad insurance protection so they can build, grow, and protect their future with confidence.

Rooted in Our Community

Welcome to Hometown Insurance, one of New York State's leading independent insurance agencies. Proudly serving individuals, families, and businesses since 1979, we provide customized home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance, and specialty coverage solutions throughout Long Island and New York State.


While our agency has grown over the years, our core values remain the same. We continue to uphold the traditions established by our founders and the high standards of service and professionalism that our clients have trusted for generations.


Our formula for success is simple: we treat our neighbors like family. As an independent agency, our team works as your personal insurance advisors—using our experience to help you find the right home, auto, or business insurance coverage at the most competitive price.


Give Us a Call Today
Hometown Family

Meet The Team

Our insurance producers and customer service representatives meet New York State's strict licensing, testing, and education requirements. We are committed to continuing education and professional development, ensuring our team stays up to date on the latest home, auto, and business insurance policies, regulations, and risk management strategies. This allows us to provide knowledgeable guidance and exceptional service to every client we serve.

Executive Management

Rebecca Weber, CPCU

President & Chief Executive Officer

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker / Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Eric Keiffert, CPCU

Executive Vice President

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker / Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Joanie LaFemina, CPSP™

Vice President of Human Resources & Marketing

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

James Small, CIC

Vice President of Sales

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Commercial Lines

Julia Keiffert, CIC, CRIS

Director of Operations

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Annabelle Olmedo

Commercial Senior Account Executive

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

John DiPalma, CRIS

Commercial Sales Broker

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Harry Fritzen

Renewal Underwriter

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

John Machalski III, CRIS

Commercial Account Executive, Brokerage Division

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Pasquale Burdo

Commercial Account Executive

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Gerard Fitzpatrick, CIC

Commercial Account Executive

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Linda Otero

Commercial Account Executive

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Michael Paglino, CIC

Commercial Account Executive

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Personal Lines

Stacy Moutafis

Director of Personal Lines

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Jack Tramuta

Personal Lines Sales Broker

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker / Licensed Life Agent / Independent Adjuster

Faith Lambert

Personal Lines Sales Broker

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Thomas Kidby

Personal Lines Account Representative

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker / Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Leslie Rendon

Personal Lines Account Representative

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Jaime Majano

Personal Lines Account Representative

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Frances Aniello Manziak

Personal Lines CSR Assistant

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Vincent Russo

Personal Lines CSR Assistant

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Firefighters & LOSAP

Robert Sagistano

Senior Vice President

Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Kevin Parrett

Vice President LOSAP Administration

Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker / Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Teresa Cowan

Operations Supervisor

Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Donna Rooney

Service Award Program Specialist

Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Jacob Keiffert

Service Award Program Specialist

Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker / Licensed Personal Lines Broker

Michele Latzen

Service Award Program Specialist

Licensed Life, Accident & Health Broker

Claims & Certificates

Ryan Boos

Claims and Certificate Coordinator

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Amy Trinkle

Claims and Certificate Coordinator

Licensed Property & Casualty Broker

Accounting

Steven Bucci

Accounting Manager

Lauren Cusumano

Accounting Assistant

Theresa Puleo

Accounting Assistant

Administration

Veronica Schoenewolf

Part-Time Admin Assistant

Sandra Wess

Admin Assistant, Reception

Marketing

Gabrielle Comanda

Marketing & HR Assistant

Technology

David Kane

CTO

How can we help you today?

Choose an insurance category to learn more about our specialized protection.